
Soft Parenting and Soft Pulpiteering: Two Orchards, One Root System
A tree is known by its fruit. That is how Christ tells us to judge a thing. Not by its mission statement. Not by its sentimental ideals. Not by how carefully its practitioners speak about it. Look at the fruit. Look at what it produces. That is the truth.
I’ve had ample opportunity to walk through the orchards of the modern home and the modern church, I find the same mushy harvest in both places. Soft people who expect authority to bend toward them. Congregations trained to wilt at the slightest moral demand. Humans shaped by softness who insist that softness is the highest virtue. I myself have not been unscathed by the state of the orchards. I have ruined my supper more than once gorging on their rotten fruits.
Let me show you what I mean.
Scene One: Aisle 7, Where Civilization Goes to Die
Imagine yourself in the grocery store. You turn a corner and stumble into the ritual of the gentle parent, which looks something like a hostage negotiation carried out in soft pastels.
A boy, no more than five, is screaming like a feral howler monkey over a bag of fluorescent sugar rocks. His mother crouches down as if approaching a wounded forest creature.
“Honey, use your words. Tell mommy how you feel right now.”
How does he feel? Judging by the kicks landing on her kneecaps, he feels like unleashing a coup. Mom offers options, as gentle parents do. “Would you like this snack instead? Or this one? Or we can go home and talk it out?”
The boy responds by attempting to claw her face.
The problem here is not gentleness; it’s confusion. She is trying to apply grace to a moment that is begging for law. She’s using a diffuser where she needs a paddle. She’s whispering therapy into the void while her son reenacts the French Revolution.
And here is the crucial line: Kids raised this way grow into adults who expect every authority, including pastors, to cater to them exactly the same way. The home trains the palate. And we’ve trained a generation to prefer spiritual baby food.
Which brings us to the pulpit.
Scene Two: The Whispering Pulpit and the Cult of Holy Niceness
Many modern pulpits preach like that mother kneeling in aisle 7. The pastor steps up with a tone softer than velvet and twice as flimsy. His sermon floats along like a dandelion puff: pretty, inoffensive, and entirely allergic to landing anywhere specific. No named sins. No pointed applications. No confronting the actual lives, of the actual people, in the actual community sitting right in front of him.
Instead, no matter the tightness of his exposition, no matter the number of hours he spent parsing out greek/hebrew sentences, he’s going to serve up the same five food groups of “gospel-centered” mush:
You need to love Jesus more.
You need to pray more.
You need to read your Bible more.
You need to feel God’s presence more.
You need to come/give to, and/or serve in his church more.
This is Christianity for people whose main spiritual battle is vague discouragement.
Meanwhile, their marriages are cracked, their sons are addicted, their daughters are drowning in self-hatred, and they’re all being discipled more by TikTok than by Titus. But the gentle pulpit cannot call anything by its name. It prefers abstraction because abstraction never hits anyone between the eyes. And so congregations remain in a perpetual adolescence, enthusiastic about “my spiritual journey,” thin-skinned as butterfly wings, and allergic to anything resembling correction. Lewis called them “men without chests,” upper brains full of theological trivia, lower guts full of religious emotion, and nothing in between to bind the two into courage.
These men are not rare. In fact, they flourish under gentle pulpiting like mold in a damp basement. The next time you are in Louisville, take a stroll at Southern Seminary on a crisp fall morning. Drink in the spectacle. The campus is full of polite, high-achieving, chestless seminarians, growing like orchids in the meticulously climate-controlled greenhouse of evangelical gentility. Or as my favorite baptist Jerry Dorris puts it, the place is practically sustained by “seminary sugar mammas,” a pietistic welfare system that rewards soft-spoken fragility and punishes conviction with a raised eyebrow. I watched more than once, a man with a chest come under church discipline (in a church pastored by professors) for getting a little too outspoken about CRT, feminism, or reformed political theology.
The Fruit Never Lies
A tree is known by its fruit. Gentle parenting yields adults who don’t respect authority unless it whispers sweetly.
Gentle pulpiting yields Christians who don’t obey Scripture unless it arrives scented with lavender. If the sermon dares to call out pornography, feminism, laziness, materialism, cowardice, bitterness, or gossip, specifically, concretely, it’s considered mean. If a pastor applies the text to the headlines, he’s being “political.” If he says anything sharper than a marshmallow, the email inbox fills up by Monday.
The fruit never lies.
Soft pulpits make soft saints.
Soft saints make soft churches.
Soft churches crumble into spiritual adolescence.
Yes, There’s a Ditch on the Other Side
Some pastors overcorrect and turn the pulpit into a partisan teleprompter. Every sermon becomes a State of the Union. Every text gets dragged into the outrage of the week. This too is folly. But at least it has testosterone. Still, it cannot form mature Christians because it replaces discipleship with adrenaline. It gets cheap amens in middle America because it testifies that the real problem with the world is "out there." Rather than avoiding the individual and household sins of a congregation, this approach shifts the blame altogether. The end-result is the same: no one repents.
This sort of blame shifting produces Nick Fuentes types. Men who look anywhere and everywhere for answers to why their life sucks, rather than just checking the most obvious place: the mirror. If it's everyone else's responsibility, it can't be mine. Yet, responsibilty is exactly what a boy must take on to become a man.
What Shepherds and Fathers Must Learn
Paul told Timothy that a man must prove himself in his home before he proves himself in the church. Why? Because the home is where a man learns the sacred dance of law and gospel.
A father must discipline and delight.
Correct and comfort.
Command and embrace.
Say “no” with authority and “yes” with generosity.
Pastors must do the same. Not the soft, whispering vacillation of gentle pulpiting. Not the feverish bark of political pulpiteering.
But the steady, straight-backed, warm-blooded authority of a shepherd who knows who he is, knows what the Word says, and knows how to apply it to the real world his people wake up to every morning. For those searching for a new "third-way" here it is, long-cut. Get yourself a big pinch, pack it in tight, and make sure you inhale.
Soft Parenting Makes Soft Churches
Because both are allergic to the same thing: authority.
Gentle parenting treats authority as a suggestion.
Gentle pulpiting treats Scripture as a sentiment.
Both raise people who believe all power must come with a padded surface and a soothing tone.
But Christ is not a therapist with a Galilean counseling license.
Christ is King.
King over children.
King over households.
King over pulpits.
King over headlines.
King over nations.
Soft pulpits collapse in soft times.
We are not living in soft times.
It’s time for pastors to command and guide like fathers.
It’s time for Christians to obey like disciples.
It’s time for households to raise oaks, not orchids.
And it’s time for the gentle pulpits of our age to give way to the full-throated, steel-spined, grace-and-law proclamation of the risen King.







